Tuesday, July 8, 2008

Claim Rejections Based On Large References

Can an Examiner reject a claim by selecting from a patent reference a large number of widely separated and logically unrelated passages, in cookie-cutter fashion, in order to cover the various concepts recited by the claims? The PTO Rules of Practice require the examiner to cite only what he considers the best references. Multiplying references, any one of which is as good as, but no better than, the others, adds to the burden and cost of prosecution and should therefore be avoided.

The Appeals Board held that similar observations apply to citing parts of an individual reference. "The Examiner is not called upon to cite all parts of a reference that may be available but only the best. Multiplying citations to parts or a reference, any one of which is as good as, but no better than, the others, adds to the burden and cost of prosecution." So the answer is no.

See: Ex Parte Dewing et al Appeal No. 2008-0026 (BPAI July 9, 2008)

Labels: , , , ,

7 Comments:

At February 13, 2012 at 6:24 PM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Yeah, but if he doesn't cite all those in the reference application you'll argue the one he did and then demand a 2nd action non-final because he didn't cite the "correct" portion of the reference. Better to just cite everything.

 
At May 10, 2021 at 4:58 AM , Blogger Elina Rose said...

KineMaster makes video editing fun on your phone, tablet, or Chromebook! KineMaster makes it easy to edit videos with lots of powerful tools, downloadable content, and much more.KineMaster is completely free to use, but you can unlock even more with a KineMaster Premium subscription! A subscription removes the KineMaster watermark and offers an ad-free experience. Learn more by tapping the crown button on the main screen kinemasterdown.

 
At June 10, 2021 at 5:51 AM , Blogger Unknown said...

It was a fun way to make activities engaging, challenging, different, or novel. Doing an old activity in a new way helps develop new brain pathways. It can help a child experience an activity without triggering a pain response, helping make a new association between a physical movement and less perceived pain. This item is great for providing small motor coordination reinforcement. Little nut-nuts are important for little hands to learn to hold on to. There are many activities in which the nut family can participate, so that manipulation of the various objects allows for the child to learn real-world skills in a fun way www.mytoysandgames.com.

 
At June 16, 2021 at 7:44 AM , Blogger Elina Rose said...

This app allows gardeners and landscapers to create quick work reports for every customer, thus, providing a detailed list of completed gardening services. You can precisely record the time you spend on each task software for CEA Growers. This can then be used for improved project planning, time management, and optimal calculation of services for invoicing.Do you work on landscaping or gardening tasks? Would you like to record completed work as soon as you finish?

 
At July 9, 2021 at 7:03 AM , Blogger Unknown said...

Not every laptop on the market can handle 3D design software and applications, so choosing the right device takes time, patience, and knowledge of the minimum specs for designing in 3D. This is one of the most graphically-intensive tasks, and it requires a lot more than just high resolution and fast processing Click Here.

 
At September 14, 2021 at 11:55 PM , Blogger FREE APPS said...

Really good blog, best graphics android games, and gameplay, this game is one of the best battle royale android mobile games that a player can enjoy.

 
At September 26, 2021 at 6:16 PM , Blogger Roller Talk said...

Good blog I really love how nice it is on my eyes. I’m wondering how I could be notified whenever a new post has been made.
I have subscribed to your feed which may do the trick? Have a great day! Click here

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home